|
Renal health professionals are beginning to mine and analyse the wealth
of data being generated by the Dialysis Outcomes and Practice Patterns
Study, conference delegates heard.
This longitudinal study of haemodialysis patients now involved
20 units in the UK, Dr Roger Greenwood, Chairman of the session,
Highlights from IDOPPS, said.
"After many months of hard work by many individual people
the results of DOPPS have started to trickle though over the last
12 months and have created many discussions.
"So a DOPPS session at the symposium was thought to be very
informative," Dr Greenwood, who is Clinical Director at the
Lister Hospital, Stevenage, explained.
Dr Sean Leavey, of the University of Michagan, set the scene by
explaining what DOPPS was intended to achieve.
Where observational
studies score. He stressed that, as an observational
study, its major advantage was that it allowed us to test some parameters
which could not be tested in a clinical-trial setting because of
feasibility or ethical limitations.
He went on to illustrate his theme by telling delegates that data
from the survey suggested that mild to moderate obesity might improve
survival among haemodialysis patients.
"Observational studies describe the actual treatment practices.
They can test numerous hypotheses and they can address the questions
that are not accessible to be addressed by clinical trials,"
Dr Leavey said.
"Findings can lead to new trials and, while correlation and
association from observational research does not prove causation.
If you multiply, adjust for confounding factors, take the necessary
adjustments into account, and you see consistency across different
studies, then you begin to get data which can provide reasonable
inferences for practising physicians," he concluded.
Renal disease affects people of all ages and a section of DOPPS
has aimed to clarify whether both the treatment and the outcomes
vary according to the age of the patient, the session heard.
Heather Jayasekera, Research & Practice Development Sister
at Hope Hospital, Salford, has been looking at patient mortality,
their hospitalisation, their vascular access, and their quality
of life in relation to age. How
age influences outcome.
"The data analysis from the DOPPS study has confirmed:
 |
 |
l
the risk of death rate increases with age, |
| |
 |
the
risk of hospitalisation increases with age, |
| |
 |
the
patients' physical quality of life decreases with age while
their mental quality of life remains relatively constant,"
|
"And our older patients are less likely to start haemodialysis
with a functioning fistula while our younger patients are less likely
to start haemodialysis with permanent access," she said.
Nurse team leader in the Haemodialysis Unit at the Lister Hospital,
Stevenage, Victoria Riggs then told the session that she, too, had
been using the DOPPS data to look at the health differences among
age groups of haemodialysis patients within the study.
Elderly haemodialysis patients
risk malnutrition. She had looked especially at health
differences and adherence to diet among age groups in the seven
participating countries: France Germany, Italy, Japan Spain UK and
USA.
She had found that elderly haemodialysis patients were more likely
to suffer from malnutrition but were less likely to skip dialysis
sessions, she said.
In response to a question from the floor, Victoria Riggs agreed
that renal units could, where appropriate, consider feeding patients
while they dialyse to combat this problem.
Returning to Dr Leavey's theme in the final presentation of the
session, Dr Hugh Rayner, Medical Director of Birmingham Heartlands
Hospital, stressed that DOPPS was a study in progress and a lot
of the data that had been discussed at the session was the baseline
description of the populations being studied.
UK lags in fistula race.
"There is clearly a lot more analysis of this enormous database
that needs to be done and will be done," he said.
"This presentation is designed to demonstrate what questions
can be asked and to get some evidence behind our practice patterns
where they have largely been built upon tradition and urban mythology.
"The biggest issue we have in the UK is getting fistulas created
and getting them usable. We therefore rely on a large number of
temporary catheters.
"If we had a more efficient way of creating fistulas and then
using them, this would reduce the time period in which temporary
access may be required."
However, in this country, the use of the fistula tended to be delayed
because current practice cautioned that if you needled the fistula
early, you might traumatise it, damage it and reduce its long-term
survival, he explained.
"So, I was interested to see whether the DOPPS database could
tell us whether this practice pattern was based on any real evidence,"
Hugh Rayner said.
And he found that early needling of fistulas did not seem to jeopardise
their long-term survival.
But this finding did not answer the most significant concern, which
had emerged from his research.
"The two major issues so far coming out of DOPPS are dialysis
dose and access. Dialysis dose in the UK at the moment is pretty
equivalent to the rest of Europe, but access is our huge weakness
and we've got to do something about it," Hugh Rayner concluded.
During the lunch interval an extensive exhibition of poster presentations
was staffed by their authors and three in particular caught nephronline's
eye.
If you would like more information about DOPPS send an email to
info@nephronline.org
Renal technicians want more status
Renal technicians want more status and to be more widely recognised
as an integral part of the kidney-patient care team, according to
spokesman for the Association of Renal Technicians Mark Forrest[link
to article More status, please, say technicians]. They would also
like to see greater standardisation of their line management.
He told nephronline: "We really need to enhance the
status of renal technicians.
"In a lot of units the technician is not a part of the team.
We need to promote the team cause.
"Our overall maintenance role is probably going down as machines
are being built better. They run better. The service intervals have
increased and mean time between failures has improved. The days
when we just soldered circuit boards have gone," he said.
Renal pharmacists launch FAQ booklet
Pharmacists at the Royal Free Hospital, London, have come up with
an information booklet to answer the most common questions they
get from the renal healthcare team and patients during the summer
months. Travel
vaccines vade mecum
"Especially in the summer months, we're forever being telephoned
by health professionals or patients asking: Which vaccines can I
use in transplant patients? Which vaccines can I use in dialysis
patients? Which malaria can they safely take? So, we thought we'd
do a leaflet," renal pharmacist Caroline Ashley told nephronline.
"But the telephone calls are not going down because word has
gone out that we've done it so we get telephone calls about that
now!" she added.
Exercise works out in dialysis
Following on from her successful cycling while dialysing regime,
clinical scientist at the Lister Hospital, Stevenage, Chiew Kong
is encouraging patients to exercise between dialysis sessions.
Exercising isn't naff
Her poster presentation at Nephrology in Practice 2001 described
how she had linked up with a local health club to arrange three-months
free use by 10 patients. Each had pre-training assessment and a
fitness test by a fitness instructor and a training programme was
drawn up for each individual patient.
At the end of the three months the fitness test was repeated. The
patients were also asked their views of their physical fitness both
before and after the trial.
Her idea of linking up with heath club was to overcome resistance
from some patients to exercise, especially the young, Chiew Kong
told nephronline.
"Some people consider cycling during dialysis as naff, especially
the younger ones or maybe the bike doesn't give them the level of
exercise that they want," she said.
"Another reason is to shift the emphasis or focus from sickness
to health. It might make exercise more appealing, more sexy to them.
'I want to be with these healthy people exercising.' So, that was
the rational behind getting them to the gym to exercise," she
explained.
Healthy Heart, Healthy Start
A packed afternoon included a session called Healthy Heart, Healthy
Start, during which specialist registrar in renal medicine at Ninewells
Hospital, Dundee, Dr Graham Stewart told delegates that boosting
haemoglobin levels in patients approaching dialysis appeared to
regress left-ventricular hypertrophy. Treating
anaemia regresses LVH.
"The effect of this on subsequent end-stage renal failure
cardiovascular mortality isn't yet known, but is an exciting potential
therapeutic option," he said.
He explained that LVH was common in patients approaching end-stage
renal failure (ESRF) and was seen early in the progression of the
disease. He outlined the aetiology of the condition in the uraemic
patient and went on to describe the health problems it could cause.
But there was hope on the horizon, he continued.
There had been several studies that have shown that if you can
partially correct the anaemia in end-stage renal disease you can
partially regress the left ventricular hypertrophy, he said.
According to these studies, LVH was present at the early stages
of progressive renal disease and increased with the decline in renal
function and correlated very closely with the fall in haemoglobin.
This suggested, he continued, that early normalisation of haemoglobin
and the treatment of other cardiac risk factors might improve survival.
"And we now believe that correcting anaemia with recombinant
erythropoietin in patients with ESRF regresses LVH. Unfortunately,
we still do not know how this will affect mortality," he concluded.
Innovative practice
When the term nurse consultant was first really taken on board
by the Department of Health within its White Paper, Making a
Difference, it came as a bit of a shock to many people, including
some within the DOH, Frances Coldstream, Nurse Consultant at Guy's
and St Thomas' Hospital Trust, London, told another afternoon session.
Nurse consultants pivotal to pre-dialysis
care
"Within this document there was no definition of a nurse consultant
as such. And it is still not clear whether there is a definition,"
she said.
But Making a Difference was not just about launching the
nurse consultant role, she continued. It looked at the role's potential
within the NHS.
One road would be to use the recommendations of a framework document
from the Kidney Alliance, which the Alliance hopes will be used
by a variety of people and groups to improve equity and quality
in renal care, she said.
Frances Coldstream then discussed the seven national service standards
this document set out and how nurse consultants could play a key
role in the provision of pre-dialysis care.
"Both the developing role of the nurse consultant and the
area of pre-dialysis care are exciting developments which can be
brought together to enhance patient care. For information about
The Pre-dialysis Forum send an email to info@predialysis.org
"Both areas merit interest and research to take what has been
achieved so far forward," Frances Coldstream concluded.
In his welcoming letter to the conference, president of the British
Renal Symposium Dr Donal O'Donoghue hoped that delegates would enjoy
participating in the symposium. Judging from the number of questions
from the floor each presentation generated it seemed his hopes were
fulfilled.
|